Heheh... I suppose to say that I don't care is probably a bit harsh - I think it's partly a general reaction to the majority of fandom's infatuation with Rose; I always have to take the opposite line ;-)

And yes, my reaction to the "how come she chose to stay" was the same as yours actually - she didn't get a choice. And neither did Donna.

I mean yeah, she kissed him

Well, who wouldn't? ;-)