To write someone OOC you have to have given us an idea of exactly what is IN character for them... and part of my problem with Eleven is that I don't really know what that is, yet. I think he's repressed, he's cagey, he lies, he's got a quick temper and of course he's pretty bonkers. But like I've just said in a comment upthread, I can't quite see how he relates to Nine and Ten - Ten was very different to Nine in many ways, but we could at least see where he'd come from.

It's a while since I watched Vampires, but I thought that Eleven did offer Signora whotsit the chance to go somewhere else and she turned him down.