Pod!Rose was intelligent and mature and forgiving and not prone to jealous rages. She even cried less! But sadly that wasn't what Rose was usually like, so it's OOC for her :( I kind of got the sense that Moffat didn't care that much about RTD's companions, such that he didn't always bother with stuff like Martha's love for the Doctor or Donna's supposedly not fancying Ten. I should have a think and work out who else was like that. I mean Chibnall I think it's just lack of skill rather than lack of interest, y'know?

Did he really never touch them? I thought that was just S1, when he was saying that Moff must be good because he couldn't find anything to change in his episodes? I don't think Rusty (or anyone) would keep getting a writer back who they weren't allowed to edit.