One possible explanation is that there's a whole scene, or several scenes, between the Doctor and Amelia, and the Doctor and Amy that we have not yet seen. This would explain why Amy seems to know some deep stuff about him in The Beast Below, and why she claims that he tells her everything in Amy's Choice.
We know of at least one missing scene between the Doctor and Amelia during which he told her at least one very important thing. And we have some hints that there have been other meetings--for all we know, many of them over 14 years of Amy's life.
Since Amy's smugness and arrogance are beginning to really gall me, this is about the only explanation that has any appeal for me. Because Amy as we are seeing her now is claiming a status with the Doctor that appears to be based on nothing but an inflated sense of her own attractiveness.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot
no subject
Date: 2010-05-16 09:25 pm (UTC)We know of at least one missing scene between the Doctor and Amelia during which he told her at least one very important thing. And we have some hints that there have been other meetings--for all we know, many of them over 14 years of Amy's life.
Since Amy's smugness and arrogance are beginning to really gall me, this is about the only explanation that has any appeal for me. Because Amy as we are seeing her now is claiming a status with the Doctor that appears to be based on nothing but an inflated sense of her own attractiveness.